Find out about situations where shared parenting may need more consideration.  In some cases, it may still be possible to make shared parenting work, while in other cases another parenting arrangement might be in the best interests of the child.

For a summary of five main domains that should be evaluated while considering shared parenting, see Smyth, Mcintosh, Emery & Howarth's review (pg. 162-163). These include safety and emotional security, parenting quality and the parent child relationship, child-related factors, the nature and exercise of the parenting arrangements & practical issues.

Safety 

The Risks

Experts agree when either or both parents have been violent through physical, verbal, or psychological abuse of the other parent, a comprehensive assessment is necessary before a shared parenting plan is considered

Such violence can be destructive to a parents’ ability to raise their children with the sensitivity and structure that would promote family safety and wellbeing. 

Moreover, family violence negatively affects children's wellbeing directly and a child’s chance of healthy development is diminished when if a child is directly involved in the conflict. 

Research from Australia has found that where mothers report safety concerns, child wellbeing is lower regardless of the care arrangement, but that this is worse for children in shared time arrangements. it is important to recognize that both mothers and fathers can cause concern for safety.

Moreover, in cases of violence, extra concern should be taken as the cooperation inherent in shared parenting arrangements creates numerous opportunities for the perpetrator to continue patterns of manipulation, violence, and control on the other parent. (Pruett & DiFonzo)

Smyth, Mcintosh, Emery & Howarth suggest that the following aspects should be considered when assessing not only physical safety but also emotional security of a shared parenting arrangement:

  • each parent’s current capacity to keep the child physically safe
  • each parent’s established caregiving relationship with the child is one in which the child finds adequate comfort and support
  • the parenting arrangement neither exposes the child to violent, threatening behaviors by one or both parents nor perpetuates fear within either parent
  • the parenting arrangement protects the child from witnessing or being drawn into intense interparental conflict, hostile levels of contempt, extreme levels of unresolved anger or grief, and/or dysfunctional communication

Getting Help

Relationships Scotland makes the following recommendations for those who are concerned about safety:

If you have concerns about your own safety, the following organisations may be able to help:

Scottish Domestic Abuse Helpline 0800 027 1234

Scottish Women’s Aid

Abused Men in Scotland

Men’s Advice Line

Galop Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual and Trans (LGBT) Domestic Violence charity

Shakti Women’s Aid helps black minority ethnic women, children and young people

Scottish Families affected by Alcohol and Drugs

  • If you have concerns about your own safety, or the safety of your children, because of violence or abuse, alcohol or substance misuse, or other issues, professional advice and help is recommended.
  • If you or your child is in immediate danger, you should contact the police on 999 straight away.
  • You can get advice and support from your local Social Work Department.

If you have concerns about your children’s safety, the following organisations may be able to help:

ChildLine 0800 1111

Parentline 08000 28 22 23

The Hideout a website to help children and young people understand domestic abuse